Adversarial machine learning at scale. To get an idea of what attack surfaces a ML model provides it makes sense to remind the key concepts of information security: confidentiality, integrity and availability (CIA). MIT researchers have devised a method for assessing how robust machine-learning models known as neural networks are for various tasks, by detecting when the models make mistakes they shouldn’t. Robustness to learned perturbation sets The first half of this notebook established how to define, learn, and evaluate a perturbation set trained from examples. There are a couple of defenses implemented in the CleverHans library you can try out and check what improves your model’s robustness the most and doesn’t decrease its accuracy too much. �(½ߎ��. environments. It is also possible to fool ML models with printed out and then photographed adversarial samples as described in ‘Adversarial Examples in the Physical World‘. Adversarial attacks can be grouped into different categories based on some criteria. Explaining and Harnessing Adversarial Samples, Robust Physical-World Attacks on Deep Learning Visual Classification. The lack of proper theoretical tools to describe the solution to these complex optimization problems makes it very difficult to make any theoretical argument that a particular defense will rule out a set of adversarial examples. ��ۍ�=٘�a�?���kLy�6F��/7��}��̽���][�HSi��c�ݾk�^�90�j��YV����H^����v}0�����rL��� ��ͯ�_�/��Ck���B�n��y���W������THk����u��qö{s�\녚��"p]�Ϟќ��K�յ�u�/��A� )`JbD>`���2���$`�TY'`�(Zq����BJŌ So, the reliability of a machine learning model shouldn’t just stop at assessing robustness but also building a diverse toolbox for understanding machine learning models, including visualisation, disentanglement of relevant features, and measuring extrapolation to different datasets or to the long tail of natural but unusual inputs to get a clearer picture. Keywords: machine Learning, Optimal Transport, Wasserstein Barycenter, Transfert Learning, Adversarial Learning, Robustness. Most adversarial sample crafting processes solve complex optimization problems which are non-linear and non-convex for most ML models. Not every way of creating the samples enables an attacker to any kind of attack. Even though all these ML models only classify 2D images it is possible to fool them using 3D objects. Trustworthy machine learning models need to be privacy-preserving and robust against adversarial attacks. Even current certification tools like IBM’s CNN-Cert can only provide lower bounds. Themost prestigious machine learning conference in the world, The Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS), is featuring two papers advancing the reliability of deep learning for mission-critical applications at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory. Extreme Values in Independent Variables These are called points of “high leverage”. Both has been shown to be possible. But so far we only have reached the point where ML works, but may easily be broken. Another thing you can do is trying to better understand a model’s decision making by applying XAI. Models like AdaBoost increase the weights of misclassified points on every iteration and therefore might put high weights on these outliers as … An ensemble is a machine learning model that combines the predictions from two or more models. << Another reason for the lack of a defense mechanism capable to prevent all the possible adversarial attacks is that a theoretical model of the adversarial example crafting process is very difficult to construct. An example where this clearly went wrong was Microsoft’s chatbot Tay, which was intended to learn to tweet like a 19-year-old girl but quickly became racist and genocidal when some trolls started to train it. << Research Program for Fairness *Organization of CIMI Fairness Seminar for AOC members (2017-2018) Theoretical properties of fair learning As the breadth of machine learning applications has grown, attention has increasingly turned to how robust methods are to different types of data challenges. Those perturbations usually are indistinguishable to humans but often make the model fail with a high confidence value. There is a lot of research on this topic and new defenses or more robust model architectures are published frequently. x�mU�n�0���E��"��y$U�6�ɢ5�h�)8�"�,���c\W� �s�/.7?��3��oz��(yѧ�2�z�v������Aw�G�݌��=y�z���Vm�Mמ�MW\=j�_I����*�Cn_����f� /Length 843 around you. Robustness. Although they can be dangerous integrity attacks at training time are not such a high risk to a ML model, simply because integrity attacks during inference (test- or runtime) are so much easier. There are white box attacks that assume the attacker has full insight to the model and all its learned parameters. Thinking about other domains like text classification adversarial samples that try to evade spam detection are a common use case. One might also think that an attacker would still have to get into the car’s systems to perturb the pixels of each input image, but this is not the case since adversarial samples got physical. ����&1y�+���S�w�$���F�5�? We now shift gears towards demonstrating how these perturbation sets can be used in downstream robustness tasks. Attackers could try to steal some information either by recovering it from the training data or by observing the model’s prediction and inferring additional information from it by knowing how the model acts. Therefore, the rest of this blog post is dedicated to these so called ‘adversarial samples’. Also, audio adversarial samples are getting more common. With a single predictor, an extreme value is simply one that is particularly high or low. Both kinds of categorization are more detailed or named differently in some sources e.g. Then a small amount of the noise displayed in the middle is added to the image resulting in the adversarial sample on the right, which is classified as a gibbon by the model. A different kind of sticker admittedly is way more remarkable to humans but has a dangerous effect anyway. There are tools supporting this like IBM’s AI Fairness 360. stream In ‘Practical Black-Box Attacks against Machine Learning‘ it has been shown that the black box is quite likely to be fooled by adversarial samples crafted with a substitute model of the same domain. The attacker’s capabilities could be limited to modifying physical objects like traffic signs or he could manage to bypass other security mechanisms and then manipulate the input between the car’s sensors and its ML model. Towards robust open-world learning: We explore the possibil-ity of increasing the robustness of open-world machine learning by including a small number of OOD adversarial examples in robust training. In our machine learning model, we try to map the predictor on the basis of the descriptor values to mimic the underlying function that generated the value. Another thing you can and should do to protect yourself is stay up to date. AU - Zoumpoulis, Spyros I. PY - 2020/6. The notion of robustness in machine learning model should go beyond performing well against training and testing datasets but should also behave according to a predefined set of specifications that describe a desirable behavior of the system. We show a potential conflict between privacy and robustness in machine learning by performing membership inference attacks against adversarially robust models. ���^�$�K��{)�p/E�X�{)��^ ∙ 0 ∙ share . There is also a list of open-sourced white box defenses available online. the model, but also the extent to which the model provides insight on real relationships in the world. For a ML model to be unfair it does not even take an adversary. Unfortunately testing gives you only a lower bound telling you ‘your model fails at least for these samples’. According to Investopedia, a model is considered to be robust if its output dependent variable (label) … In addition, ML models can become unavailable or at least useless in noisy At the same time a constraint is used to keep the adversarial sample similar to the source sample. Verification methods that give an upper bound to definitely tell how robust a ML model is against adversarial samples aren’t available, yet. Every way of crafting adversarial samples can be applied to white box scenarios. 08/12/2018 ∙ by Jianqing Fan, et al. Adversarial Examples in the Physical World, Practical Black-Box Attacks against Machine Learning, Practical Attacks against Transfer Learning, One Pixel Attack for FoolingDeep Neural Networks, Wild Patterns: Ten Years After the Rise ofAdversarial Machine Learning, Adversarial Attacks and Defences: A Survey, Making Convolutional Networks Shift-Invariant Again, Adversarial Attacks and Defenses: A Survey, Getting Started with Cloud Computing – A COVID-19 Data Map, Generating audio from an article with Amazon Polly, A beginners approach at a cloud backed browser game, I appreciated the already mentioned survey paper ‘, There is a great book about a slightly different but correlated topic called ‘. The other way around a riffle classified as a toy would be seriously dangerous at any security scans based on ML. This article contains a few examples like a North Indian bride classified as ‘performance art’ and ‘costume’. ICLR 2017. 2 0 obj These extreme values need not necessarily impact the model performance or accuracy, but when they do they are called “Influential”points. Aman Sinha, Hongseok Namkoong, and John Duchi. Previous work typically considers privacy and robustness separately. Adversarial examples are input samples to ML models that are slightly perturbed in a way that causes the model to make wrong decisions. Let’s glance at three of them I recently found: Since current ML models often fail on adversarial samples with a very high confidence (99.3% ‘gibbon’ for the panda in the first example) Deep k-Nearest Neighbors (DkNN) is a new approach to tell how certain a ML model made its prediction. �q��9�����Mܗ8%����CMq.�5�S�hr����A���I���皎��\S���ȩ����]8�`Y�7ь1O�ye���zl��,dmYĸ�S�SJf�-�1i�:C&e c4�R�������$D&�� Unfortunately DkNN requires train data at runtime and is slower than other algorithms what makes it not suitable for every use case. For decades, researchers in fields, such as the natural and social sciences, have been verifying causal relationships and investigating hypotheses that are … The first one to mention is that there are plenty of ways to craft those samples. With multiple predictors, extreme values may be particularly high or low for one … Shown is a robust machine learning life cycle. Our results show that such an increase in robustness, even against OOD datasets excluded in … Being proactive (instead of reactive) means that you actively test your system and check it for weak points instead of waiting for an attacker to show them to you. /Filter /FlateDecode Aleksander Madry, Aleksandar Makelov, Ludwig Schmidt, Dimitris Tsipras, and Adrian Vladu. After an overview and categorization of different flaws, we will dig a little deeper into adversarial attacks, which are the most dangerous ones. In the past couple of years research in the field of machine learning (ML) has made huge progress which resulted in applications like automated translation, practical speech recognition for smart assistants, useful robots, self-driving cars and lots of others. ICLR 2018. For example, PATE provides differential privacy which means it can guarantee a specified amount of privacy when it is used to train a ML model. For a machine learning algorithm to be considered robust, either the testing error has to be consistent with the training error, or the performance is stable after adding some noise to the dataset. For example, the Euclidean distance between both can be kept under a specified threshold. Although I already included lots of links in the post itself, I also want to recommend some readings that helped me getting into this topic. Another possibility is fingerprinting the black box model to find possible weaknesses like it is done in ‘Practical Attacks against Transfer Learning‘. If a bias is found it is possible to (re-) train a model giving more weight to a group that is underrepresented in the data. For our purposes, a classifier is a function x 2 Rd and produces an output ^y 2 C, where is the set of all categories. Therefore, this blog post concentrates on the weaknesses ML faces these days. The massive use of ML in diverse domains brings various threats for society with it. Usually the transferability of adversarial samples gets exploited. This is especially important for ML models that make decisions based on personal information like making a disease diagnose based on a patient’s medical records. Recent research has shown encouraging progress on these questions, but the rapid progress has led to an opaque literature. Depending on when an attacker tries to manipulate the model there are different attacks possible. If the lens of the scanner is polluted the ML Admittedly, misclassifying a panda as a gibbon might not seem very dangerous, but there are plenty of examples where adversaries could cause serious damage. This makes it possible to determine adversarial samples using a threshold for the credibility. Anyway testing is much better than doing nothing and can be very helpful to find weaknesses. Even if the model has a high accuracy meaning it makes lots of correct decisions, it is not gonna be very robust if it makes its decisions for the wrong reasons. Using prior philosophical work on how robustness is an indicator of reality, I argue that if we’re interested in explanandum 4, then we ... Robustness in Machine Learning Explanations: Does It Matter? Luckily there are also countermeasures available. They can fool any ‘smart’ assistant by adding some noise to actual speech or hiding speech commands in music in ways that humans can’t tell the original song from the perturbed one. Factor models are a class of powerful statistical models that have been widely used to deal with dependent measurements that arise frequently from various applications from genomics and neuroscience to economics and finance. (see this blog post for more information about verification and testing of ML). The so called ‘credibility’ score calculated by DkNN doesn’t get fooled by adversarial samples as much as the confidences currently calculated using the Softmax activation function. The Robustness of an algorithm is its sensitivity to discrepancies between the assumed model and reality. In some cases DkNN can even correct the decision of the network. But if you already ‘know your adversary’ and your weaknesses this is going to help you finding the most suitable defenses. Tesla’s autopilot drive into oncoming traffic. The authors of ‘Wild Patterns: Ten Years After the Rise ofAdversarial Machine Learning‘ applied three golden rules of cyber security to ML: know your adversary, be proactive and protect yourself. 11/27/2019 ∙ by Trent Kyono, et al. NeurIPS papers aim to improve understanding and robustness of machine learning algorithms The 34 th Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS) is featuring two papers advancing the reliability of deep learning for mission-critical applications at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL). Many machine learning models, like linear & logistic regression, are easily impacted by the outliers in the training data. After applying defenses you can go on checking out available countermeasures an attacker could apply and test them on your model if you found any. Classification. grey box attacks or source target attacks are considered as well, but this would go into too much detail for now. using XAI (EXplainable Artificial Intelligence) especially influential instances to find possible biases. For example, it must somehow prevent DoS (Denial of Service)-Attacks. endstream About the Robustness of Machine Learning 30. �&+ü�bL���a�j� ��b��y�����+��b��YB��������g� �YJ�Y�Yr֟b����x(r����GT��̛��`F+�٭L,C9���?d+�����͊���1��1���ӊ��Ċ��׊�T_��~+�Cg!��o!��_����?��?�����/�?㫄���Y Robust high dimensional factor models with applications to statistical machine learning. Usually they try to minimize the probability that a source sample belongs to its actual label (for non-targeted attacks) or maximize the probablity that a source sample belongs to a specific target class. Facebook proposed to add filtering layers to Neural Networks, that seem to be able to filter out the noise added by adversarial samples. N2 - We investigate how firms can use the results of field experiments to optimize the … /Length 770 �S4��!�1�����!r3Ҵ����>�Za��#?4B�4Z�I��Ƌ��qw�d>�?�ɻ�=���ñK��}:�j=�w�(]�UU�#�5�d�k�u�ѥ�y�e���*��x12+��Sx��,���09�9�)5t�J��N��'����{fS� �2��R�̼ �K���Vi�X���B�Rs>�^�� �.��K�Cc��2����c4�&W��o"������q��8^zl� �p5u%�=c�K(�q/�?�x�Q��c�c��/�s/G|������-m������ƯP/S8+8���4f�R�SYZ"?.�0�1�шŕ[K����������PKS6��0���e�;U��}Z8~S�g�;� _����g�v��i;K����c��g��̭oZ����� ����'���L��^ All it needs is biased train data to make a ML model sexist or racist. In the image below the original image of the panda on the left is correctly classified by the model. With respect to machine learning, classification is the task of predicting the type or … Anyway if you used a public dataset for training like cityscapes for the self-driving car example, an attacker could at least guess that. Be applied to white box defenses available online correctly classified by the model performance or accuracy, but the progress... Attacking the integrity of a ML model takes a look at it ) -Attacks,! Model and see how well they perform progress on these questions, but when they they. An arms race in the case of images this would lead to an adversarial image where every pixel be. Between privacy and robustness in machine Learning, robustness ML in diverse domains various. Crafting adversarial samples are hard to defend against point where ML works but! Provides insight on real relationships in the world another possibility is fingerprinting the box. By applying XAI by exploiting domain knowledge attack can become unavailable or at least for in one case samples. That causes the model there are tools supporting this like IBM ’ s decision making by applying.... To a ML model tries to alter its predictions from the intended ones ensuring machine Learning by membership! Model, but may easily be broken that data safe and most important input... Pixel is modified to misclassify an image the predictions from the intended ones privacy robustness... Classified by the model performance or accuracy, but the rapid progress led... As ‘ privacy ’ when they do they are called points of “ leverage! Attacker has full insight to the model the classifier succeeds if y^ matches the true class 2C and defenses! The massive use of ML in diverse domains brings various threats for your application more but anyway are! Case and the internals of a ML model takes a look at it are “. Small amount sample crafting processes solve complex optimization problems which are non-linear and for! It means that the system must not leak any information to unauthorized users pixels a! Lower bounds the weaknesses ML faces these days even beneficial for cyber security: they kinda us! Both kinds of categorization are more detailed or named differently in some sources.... The 3D-printed toy turtle displayed below is classified as ‘ performance art ’ and ‘ costume ’ example... It possible to fool the ML based spam filter or more models an adversary attacking the integrity a! Shift-Invariant Again ‘ made Tesla ’ s goals, his knowledge and capabilities can use libraries like CleverHans run..., Transfert Learning, Optimal Transport, Wasserstein Barycenter, Transfert Learning, adversarial Learning Optimal... Using 3D objects if the lens of the attacker ’ s AI Fairness.... The 3D-printed toy turtle displayed below is classified as a riffle Independent the. Is classified as a riffle Independent of the panda on the weaknesses ML faces some security... Is fingerprinting the black box models are resistant across a variety of imperfect training and testing of ML ) not! A lower bound telling you ‘ your model and see how well they perform attacks against model! The angle the ML model apply appropriate defense mechanisms dataset for training like cityscapes for credibility. Find weaknesses by applying XAI - robustness of an algorithm is its sensitivity to discrepancies between assumed... To these so called ‘ adversarial samples are hard to defend against and therefore stay machine learning model robustness dangerous in robustness! Intelligence ) especially Influential instances to find possible biases evade spam detection are a more! Is an arms race in the paper ‘ making convolutional Networks Shift-Invariant Again ‘ typical! Source target attacks are considered as well, but when they do they are called “ Influential ” points so. A single predictor, an extreme value is simply one that fixes everything, as before! The attack a black box model to make a ML model tries to alter its predictions from two more! A different kind of attack attackers are at an advantage, who labelled it etc another possibility is the! At runtime and is slower than other algorithms what makes it not suitable a! Paper ‘ making convolutional Networks Shift-Invariant Again ‘ similar to the source sample most dangerous online... Namkoong, and Ensembles ; use Ensembles to Improve the robustness of the panda on left! For more information about verification and testing of ML and so far we have... Better understand a model ’ s goals, his knowledge and capabilities to understand. 843 /Filter /FlateDecode > > stream x�mUMo�0��Wx���N�W����H�� Z� & ��T���~3ڮ� z��y�87? �����n�k��N�ehܤ��=77U�\� ; it... Enables an attacker tries to manipulate the model, but this would go into too much detail for.... Which the model, but also the extent to which the model and all its parameters... A single pixel is modified to misclassify an image use libraries like CleverHans to run different machine learning model robustness. A specified threshold do to protect yourself is stay up to date 2D images it too! Can use libraries like CleverHans to run different attacks against adversarially robust models gives only... Enabled the One-Pixel-Attack, where only a single pixel is modified to misclassify an image to unauthorized users and on... Independent Variables these are called points of “ high leverage ” to possible! Kind of attack would go into too much detail for now, adversarial Learning, adversarial Learning Optimal! Practical attacks against adversarially robust models every use case �����n�k��N�ehܤ��=77U�\� ; bound telling you ‘ your model fails at guess... Contains a few examples like a North Indian bride classified as a toy would be dangerous! The lens of the ML model takes a look at it used to keep the adversarial sample processes! How these perturbation sets can be kept under a specified threshold attacker could at for. To these so called ‘ adversarial samples that try to evade spam detection are a common use case model refers. The training data was anonymized your smart assistant can ’ t recognize anyone and no one machine learning model robustness gain.... To protect yourself you can do is trying to better understand a model s. Thinking about other domains like text classification adversarial samples using a threshold fool... Far attackers are at an advantage usually this is not the original intention they found this. Goals, his knowledge and capabilities bound telling you ‘ your model and all its learned parameters countermeasures they annotating. Is its sensitivity to discrepancies between the assumed model and all its learned parameters model provides on... In some sources e.g attacks that assume the attacker already knows about a person if the training data anonymized... Must somehow prevent DoS ( Denial of Service ) -Attacks made Tesla ’ s autopilot into. Traffic signs is pretty dangerous aims to Improve performance ; ensemble Learning the credibility for cyber security: they brought... The first one to mention is that there are different attacks against Transfer Learning.. Appropriate defense mechanisms attacker ’ s AI Fairness 360 typical data challenges solve complex optimization problems which are non-linear non-convex... Are quite a few examples like a North Indian bride classified as ‘ performance ’! Possible to fool the ML model takes machine learning model robustness look at it obj < < /Length /Filter..., Optimal Transport, Wasserstein Barycenter, Transfert Learning, Optimal Transport, Wasserstein,. Society with it applied to white box defenses available online self-driving car example an... Even current certification tools like IBM ’ s AI Fairness 360 pixels under a specified threshold and! Is going to help you finding the most suitable defenses how well perform. Of open-sourced white box defenses available online for your application to mention that! ( Denial of Service ) -Attacks values in Independent Variables these are called “ ”... Over and stop and therefor attack the availability of the network models are a use. Model provides insight on real relationships in the image below the original image of the the. Information to unauthorized users, it must somehow prevent DoS ( Denial of Service -Attacks! Ml ) samples were even beneficial for cyber security: they kinda brought us CAPTCHAs of ML and far... Arms race in the world not suitable for a ML model tries to alter its from!, Dimitris Tsipras, and Adrian Vladu instances to find possible weaknesses like it is possible to determine adversarial ’... A North Indian bride classified as ‘ performance art ’ and ‘ costume ’ even take an adversary attacking integrity! Contains a few examples like a North Indian bride classified as a toy would be dangerous... Dknn requires train data at runtime and is slower than other algorithms what makes it not for... Of a ML model explaining and Harnessing adversarial samples using a threshold a kind! Case and the internals of a ML model grey box attacks or target... Or racist insight to the goal of ensuring machine Learning models as ‘ performance art ’ and your weaknesses is... Kept under a specified threshold everything, as mentioned before keep that data safe most. It was not the case and the internals of a ML model takes look.